Selling Art on Etsy or Gumroad: Guide to Choosing the Right Platform

Disclosure: I may earn a small commission for purchases made through affiliate links in this post at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I truly believe in. Thank you for supporting my site!

You've created something beautiful. Maybe it's a delicate watercolor painting, a witty digital sticker, or a powerful set of social media templates.

That creation has value, and you're ready to share it with the world—and get paid for it. In the online marketplace, two names consistently stand out for creative entrepreneurs: Etsy and Gumroad.

But which one is the right stage for your art?

Choosing between them isn't about which platform is "better." It's about which one is a better fit for you, your products, and your goals.

Think of it as choosing a storefront. Etsy is like a bustling, charming craft mall with millions of visitors. Gumroad is your sleek, minimalist boutique on a quiet side street.

This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about selling art on Etsy vs. Gumroad, so you can confidently pick the path that will help your creative business thrive.

Understanding the Two Platforms: A Quick Introduction

Before we dive deep, let's define our players.

Etsy is a massive online marketplace focused on "handmade, vintage, and craft supplies." Its biggest strength is its built-in audience.

Millions of people go to Etsy every day specifically to buy unique, creative goods. When you open an Etsy shop, you're setting up a stall in the world's busiest digital craft fair.

Gumroad is a simple, powerful tool for selling digital products directly to your audience. It's not a marketplace; it's a sales platform.

There is no built-in discovery. People only find your products on Gumroad if you bring them there through your own marketing, like social media, an email list, or a personal blog.

Etsy: The Bustling Digital Craft Fair

The Pros: Why You Might Choose Etsy

1. The Built-In Audience is Everything: This is Etsy's superpower. You aren't starting from zero. Shoppers are already on the platform, searching for terms like "minimalist wall art," "wedding venue clipart," or "fitness planner." If you optimize your shop correctly, they can find you without you doing any external marketing. It’s like having a powerful river of potential customers; your job is to build a net to catch them.

   
   

2. Ideal for Physical Products: Etsy's entire system is built around shipping physical items. The platform has integrated tools for calculating shipping costs, printing labels, and managing orders. If you sell prints, stickers, original paintings, or handmade jewelry, Etsy is a natural home.

   
   

3. Trust and Credibility: For many buyers, Etsy is a trusted brand. They feel secure entering their payment information and know there's a system for resolving issues. This trust can help convert hesitant first-time buyers.

   
   

The Cons: The Challenges of the Craft Fair

1. Fees Can Add Up: Etsy isn't free. You pay a listing fee ($0.20 per item), a transaction fee (6.5% of the sale price), and a payment processing fee (3% + $0.25). If you use Etsy Ads, that's an additional cost. While each fee is small, they can eat into your profits, especially on lower-priced items.

   
   

2. You're a Small Fish in a Giant Ocean: With millions of sellers, competition is fierce. You can't just list a product and wait. You have to work hard on your SEO (Search Engine Optimization) to make sure your products appear in search results.

   
   

3. Less Control and Branding: Your shop lives within Etsy's rules and design. It can be harder to make your shop feel like a unique, standalone brand. You are, in many ways, renting space in Etsy's mall.

   
   

Gumroad: Your Personal Online Boutique

The Pros: Why You Might Choose Gumroad

1. Incredibly Simple for Digital Products: If you sell digital files—like Procreate brushes, eBooks, digital planners, or Photoshop actions—Gumroad is beautifully simple. There are no listing fees. They take a flat 10% fee only when you make a sale. The process from upload to sales page is fast and clean.

   
   

2. You Keep 100% of Your Customer List: This is a massive advantage. On Etsy, you don't really "own" your customer relationships. On Gumroad, you get the email address of every single person who buys from you. This allows you to build your own email list from day one, which is the most valuable asset for any long-term business.

   
   

3. More Control and Higher Profit Potential: Because you're driving all the traffic, you have more control over your brand experience. There are no competing products on your sales page. And since the flat fee is simple, it can be more profitable than Etsy for higher-priced digital items. Selling a $50 digital product on Gumroad costs you $5 in fees. On Etsy, the fees would be higher.

   
   

The Cons: The Challenges of the Boutique

1. No Built-In Traffic: This is Gumroad's biggest hurdle. If you don't have an audience or a marketing plan, you will make zero sales. The platform will not bring you customers. You are responsible for every single visitor who lands on your product page.

   
   

2. Not Designed for Physical Goods: While you can sell physical products on Gumroad, it's clunky. You have to handle shipping calculations and logistics manually. It lacks the integrated system that Etsy has built over years.

   
   

3. You Are the Marketer: Your success is 100% tied to your ability to promote your work. This requires comfort with social media, content creation, or email marketing.

   
   

Side-by-Side Comparison: Etsy vs. Gumroad at a Glance

Feature	Etsy	Gumroad
Best For	Physical art & crafts, low-effort marketing	Digital products, building a direct audience
Built-in Audience	✅ Yes, massive	❌ No, you bring the traffic
Fee Structure	Listing fee + Transaction fee + Payment fee	Flat 10% fee on sales
Customer Emails	Limited access	✅ You get every customer's email
Ease of Use	Moderate (more setup)	Very Simple (quick setup)
Brand Control	Limited	High

How to Decide: A Simple Flowchart for Your Business

Still unsure? Ask yourself these questions:

1. What am I selling?

   • Physical Items (prints, jewelry, originals): Lean towards Etsy. Its shipping and fulfillment tools are unmatched for makers.

   • Digital Items (PDFs, digital art, software, courses): Lean towards Gumroad. Its system is streamlined for instant digital delivery.

     
     

2. Where is my audience right now?

   • "I'm starting from zero." Lean towards Etsy. The built-in search traffic gives you a crucial starting boost.

   • "I have a social media following or an email list." Lean towards Gumroad. You can immediately start selling to your existing audience and capture their emails for future sales.

     
     

3. What is my long-term goal?

   • "I want a simple, hands-off store to sell a few things." Etsy can work well with less active marketing.

   • "I want to build a sustainable, independent brand." Gumroad helps you build the most important asset: your own customer list.

     
     

Pro Tip: You don't necessarily have to choose just one! Many successful creators use both. They use Etsy to attract new customers with lower-priced physical items or digital downloads.

Then, they include a link in their Etsy package or download area inviting those customers to join their email list for future offers, which they then fulfill through Gumroad.

This combines Etsy's discovery power with Gumroad's relationship-building strength.

Your First Steps to Getting Started

No matter which platform you choose, the foundational work is the same.

1. Perfect Your Product: Ensure your art is the best it can be. For physical items, that means high-quality materials. For digital items, that means a polished, professional file.

   
   

2. Take Stunning Photos: Your product images are your number one salesperson. Use natural light, a clean background, and show your product in use. For digital items, create mockups that help the buyer imagine using your product. A tool like Canva is fantastic for this.

   
   

3. Write Compelling Descriptions: Don't just describe what it is; describe what it does for the buyer. How will it make their life easier, more beautiful, or more organized? Use keywords that a potential customer would type into a search bar.

   
   

4. Price with Confidence: Don't undervalue your work! Factor in the cost of your materials, time, platform fees, and taxes. Your price should reflect the value you provide.

   
   

Your art deserves an audience. By understanding the unique strengths of Etsy and Gumroad, you can make a strategic choice that sets your creative business up for success.

Listen to your goals, look at your products, and take that first brave step. The world is waiting to see what you've made.